Can a Lawyer Get an EB-1A?
This discussion is about one question: does the practice of law fall under EB-1A, and can a lawyer get a petition approved?
The law requires an EB-1A applicant’s achievements to relate to one of five fields: the sciences, arts, education, business or athletics (INA §203(b)(1)(A), 8 CFR §204.5(h)(2)).
The position of the INS (the former Immigration and Naturalization Service, now USCIS)
On January 20, 1995, the INS General Counsel issued an opinion (Genco Op. 95-3) stating that since law is expressly included in the EB-2 category but not mentioned in EB-1A, it is logical to conclude that the practice of law by itself is not among the EB-1A fields. Although the EB-2 category also includes other professions (physician, architect, etc.), the opinion focused specifically on lawyers.
However, the opinion also stated that a lawyer may qualify for EB-1A if their achievements fall into one of the permitted fields — for example, business, education or the arts.
So the General Counsel’s position comes down to this:
The practice of law by itself is not an EB-1A field.
However, the fact that the applicant is a lawyer does not rule out filing for EB-1A if their achievements fall into one of the permitted fields.
Although General Counsel opinions are advisory and not binding on USCIS, the court in R.L. Inv. Ltd. Partners v. I.N.S., 86 F.Supp.2d 1014, 1022 (D. Hawaii 2000) recognized that such opinions can serve as authoritative guidance.
Current interpretation and AAO practice
Based on a number of decisions by the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO), USCIS still follows the position set out in the General Counsel opinion.
There are no USCIS precedent decisions on this issue, and no new official opinions. However, a number of AAO non-precedent decisions follow this logic: if the applicant frames their work as relating to education, business, the arts and so on, their case may be decided favorably.
Key AAO decisions:
Matter of [Redacted] (October 18, 2007): the lawyer was engaged in teaching and research. The petition was approved as relating to “education” and the “arts”.
Matter of [Redacted] (November 29, 2013): denied, because the applicant intended to continue practicing law. The AAO noted that the practice of law is not among the EB-1A fields.
Matter of J-L- (April 8, 2019): the lawyer stated that he would work in business consulting. He was a managing partner of a law firm and planned work related to business development between US and Chinese companies. USCIS denied, but the AAO withdrew the denial, finding that the applicant’s work fell under “business”, not just the practice of law.
Matter of A-Y-, ID# 3752159 (September 26, 2019): a lawyer from Kazakhstan without a US license, who studied in an LL.M. program and planned to take the New York bar exam. USCIS questioned whether her profession fell under EB-1A. The AAO withdrew the denial, stating that her work in the international legal sphere could be considered “business”, and her plan to continue her career met the requirement to “continue work in the area”. The lack of a license was not an obstacle, since a clear plan of action was submitted.
In Re: 30586318 (April 17, 2024): a lawyer from Russia without a license. USCIS again denied on the same grounds as in A-Y-. The AAO withdrew the denial, confirming that being a lawyer does not prevent EB-1A approval if the work relates to the permitted fields (science, education, the arts). The case was remanded for further review because part of the evidence was missing.
How to work around the EB-1A limitation for the legal profession
A lawyer can qualify for EB-1A if their achievements relate to one of the permitted fields:
teaching, research → education
international consulting, management → business
human rights work, public speaking → arts
Can a lawyer’s petition be approved?
Yes. General Counsel opinions are authoritative but not binding. AAO non-precedent decisions apply only to the specific cases. Keep in mind that AAO decisions are published only for USCIS denials, and many lawyers get EB-1 approvals without any appeal.
What should a lawyer planning to file for EB-1A do?
Consult an attorney to develop a filing strategy.
If you are filing on your own, think carefully about how to present your achievements.

Comments