top of page

← Back to the knowledge base

A Contract with an Attorney: What You Need to Know So You Don’t Lose Money

10 hours ago
10 min read

You have chosen the attorney you will work with to prepare your O-1, EB-1 or EB-2 NIW petition.


The next important step is to carefully review and sign the contract. A good contract does not guarantee that the petition will be approved — no attorney can guarantee that. But it helps you understand in advance:

  • what exactly the attorney commits to do;

  • what you will have to do;

  • which services are included in the price and which you will pay for separately;

  • when the work is considered complete;

  • what happens if you or the attorney decide to end the relationship.


Rules on payment, termination and refunds differ depending on the state in which the attorney is licensed. So this article is a practical checklist, not a universal interpretation of any contract.


What the contract should include


The contract should clearly describe the scope of the attorney’s work. Wording like “immigration services” or “help with a petition” is too general: it is hard to tell from it what result you will get.


If you are hiring an attorney for full representation, the contract should specify separately whether the work includes:

  • an analysis of your profile and choice of immigration category;

  • developing a strategy for the criteria;

  • recommendations on gathering evidence;

  • reviewing documents and translations;

  • preparing USCIS forms;

  • preparing the petition text or the legal brief in support of the case;

  • compiling the exhibit list and assembling the evidence into the final package;

  • preparing or editing recommendation letters;

  • a final review of the entire petition;

  • mailing the petition to USCIS or handling the online filing, if available for the relevant form;

  • giving you a complete copy of the filed petition and the USCIS receipt;

  • tracking USCIS notices after filing.


If what you need is a petition that is prepared and filed, it is better to state this directly in the contract. For example: “preparation of the complete petition package, agreement of the final version with the client, filing with USCIS, and delivery to the client of a copy of the filed package and the receipt notice”.


You should also check who is responsible for physically mailing or filing online, paying government fees and fixing technical errors if the package is returned without being accepted.


Who the attorney’s client is


This is especially important for O-1. The petition in this category is filed by a US employer or agent, so the attorney’s client may be the petitioner, the beneficiary or both — depending on the contract and whether joint representation is permissible.


If the services are paid for by a company, agent, employer or another person, that does not mean the payer is the client and gets access to all case information. The contract should make clear:

  • whom exactly the attorney represents;

  • to whom the attorney must report information;

  • who makes decisions in the case;

  • who owns the materials prepared;

  • what happens in a conflict of interest between the company and the beneficiary.


For EB-1A and EB-2 NIW, where a person self-petitions, this question is usually simpler, but the client’s name and the scope of representation should still be stated precisely.


Is an RFE or NOID response included in the price?


Be sure to check whether the price includes a response to:

  • an RFE — Request for Evidence, a request for additional evidence;

  • a NOID — Notice of Intent to Deny, a notice of intent to deny.


These are different documents, and the phrase “response to a USCIS request” may not cover both. The contract should state whether such work is included in the initial price, whether there is a limit on scope or hours, and in which cases additional payment will be required.


Also check separately whether the contract covers:

  • refiling after a denial;

  • a Motion to Reopen or Motion to Reconsider;

  • an administrative appeal;

  • the consular stage after the petition is approved;

  • preparing Form I-485 and support with obtaining a green card inside the US.


These stages are usually considered separate services. That is fine, as long as the boundaries of the work are clear in advance.


Fees and additional costs


The contract should state how the fee is calculated: a flat fee, hourly billing or a combination of both.


If the fee is flat, check:

  • for exactly what scope of work it is charged;

  • when and in what installments payment is made;

  • at what stage each installment is considered earned by the attorney;

  • how the refund is calculated if the work stops before filing;

  • whether the fee can increase, and in which specific cases.


List separately the costs not included in the attorney’s fee:

  • USCIS government fees;

  • Premium Processing, if available and you choose to use it;

  • translations and certifications;

  • expert opinions and an advisory opinion for O-1, if required;

  • a business plan or professional plan;

  • shipping and printing;

  • obtaining archival documents, statistics and paid publications;

  • work by third-party specialists.


Phrases like “non-refundable fee” or “earned upon receipt” deserve special attention. Whether such terms are permissible, and what the word retainer means, depends on the rules of the particular state. In many jurisdictions an advance payment for legal services does not automatically become fully non-refundable: if the work stops, the attorney must return the unearned portion. So ask for a written explanation of what amount may not be refunded and on what basis.


Contract vs engagement letter — what is the difference


An engagement letter is not a “letter of intent” or a document of lesser force. In US legal practice, this is often the name for the agreement in which the attorney and client formalize the start of representation, the scope of services and payment. It can be a full contract even if it is called a letter, agreement, retainer agreement or engagement agreement.


So what matters is not the name of the document but its content. Check whether it includes all the essential terms: the parties, the scope of work, the fee, costs, the client’s obligations, how you will communicate, completion and termination of representation, refund of unearned funds and transfer of the file.


Gathering evidence and preparing the portfolio


Gathering evidence is joint work between the client and the attorney.


Only you know all the details of your profession, career and achievements. So your job is to tell your story honestly and fully, provide documents and explain the professional context.


The attorney’s job, within the agreed scope of services, is to explain the legal requirements, help identify the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence, warn about risks and prepare a clear petition structure. Professional responsibility rules do not prohibit an attorney from explaining which legitimate evidence can support a criterion. But an attorney cannot advise forging documents, distorting facts or creating fictitious achievements.


Before signing the contract, clarify:

  • whether you will get an individual list of required evidence;

  • how many portfolio consultations are included in the price;

  • whether the attorney will review new achievements before you spend money on them;

  • who writes and edits recommendation letters;

  • who checks the translations;

  • whether searching for open sources and statistics is included;

  • in what form materials need to be uploaded and described.


The phrase “bring everything you have, we will sort it out” does not in itself mean poor work. But before paying, you should understand whether you will get only the legal assembly of materials you already have, or full help with strategy and evidence.


When the attorney starts preparing the petition


It is useful to agree in advance on a date after which the gathered portfolio is considered ready for writing the petition. This helps avoid endless changes and extra bills.


However, you should not write that no new documents can be added after that date at all. Until the petition is filed, an important award, publication, contract or other material may come up. It is better to set a clear procedure in the contract:

  • which changes are included in the price;

  • which changes count as substantial rework;

  • how additional payment is agreed in advance;

  • who decides whether to include a late document;

  • when the client receives the final version for review.


Do not agree to a term that allows the attorney to bill any additional amount without prior notice and your consent.


The clause on termination by the attorney


The contract usually includes conditions under which the attorney can end the representation. For example, if the client demands illegal actions, provides false information, does not pay agreed invoices, does not respond to requests, or cooperation becomes impossible because of a conflict of interest.


The wording may look like this:


Right to Terminate Representation: The Firm reserves the right to withdraw from representing you in the event that you engage in any conduct that the Firm decides would make it improper, illegal, impractical, inappropriate, and/or unethical to continue the representation under this Engagement Letter.


Such wording is very broad. Ask the attorney to explain which situations it covers and, if possible, add:

  • written notice of the problem;

  • a reasonable period to fix it, if it can be fixed;

  • how the work performed will be calculated;

  • refund of the unearned portion of the advance in accordance with the applicable rules;

  • the timeline and method for transferring the client file;

  • the attorney’s steps to protect the client’s urgent interests before ending the work.


At the same time, a contract cannot override mandatory rules of professional responsibility. Under the general approach reflected in the ABA rules, when ending representation the attorney must take reasonable steps to protect the client: give reasonable notice, allow time to find another representative, hand over the papers the client is entitled to and refund the unearned portion of the advance. The specific requirements are set by the rules of the state in which the attorney is licensed.


Public criticism of an attorney (for example, in topic chats) does not in itself automatically mean the attorney may leave the client unprotected and keep the entire payment. However, in practice there are cases where attorneys prohibit posting any negative reviews about them and are ready to terminate the contract otherwise. If an attorney does this, you should be very wary.


Contract term and completion


A limited contract term should not in itself raise suspicion. What matters is that the term is realistic and the contract explains what happens if the work drags on for reasons beyond the client’s control. Gathering evidence often takes about a year, so if the contract term is very short (for example, a few months or half a year), you should be wary.


It is better to tie completion of the work not only to a calendar date but to a clear event. For example:

  • filing the petition and giving the client a complete copy;

  • receiving the USCIS decision, if post-filing support is included in the price;

  • completing the RFE or NOID response;

  • the end of a separately agreed consular stage or I-485 process.


Also check whether the contract terminates automatically if you do not respond for a long time, and whether the attorney must send a warning first.


Form G-28 and communication with USCIS


If the attorney officially represents you before USCIS, they file Form G-28.


The contract should specify:

  • who signs and files the G-28;

  • who will receive the original notices and secure documents;

  • how quickly the firm forwards USCIS notices to the client;

  • who keeps track of response deadlines;

  • how representation ends or changes if you move to another attorney.


Separately, agree on the rules for communicating with the firm: the main contact, the working language, the means of communication, the usual response time, how often you get case updates and access to copies of documents. An attorney is obliged to keep the client reasonably informed about the case and respond to reasonable requests, but the contract will help make your expectations specific.


What else to check before signing


Pay attention to the following provisions:

  • governing law: which state’s rules apply;

  • dispute resolution: whether mandatory mediation, arbitration or a special fee dispute procedure is provided for;

  • responsible attorney: who personally oversees the case and what work is done by paralegals or other staff;

  • use of third-party services: where documents are stored and to whom information may be shared;

  • confidentiality: whether the firm may use your case, anonymized or not, in marketing, and whether separate consent is required;

  • limitation of liability: whether there is an attempt to fully release the firm in advance from liability for professional errors;

  • getting your file: in what format and within what time you will receive the forms, letters, evidence, translations, receipts and USCIS notices;

  • changes of strategy: how substantial changes to the category, the evidence or the filing method are agreed.


Do not sign a document if you do not understand part of it. Ask for a written explanation of a disputed clause or propose your own wording. An oral promise is hard to rely on in a dispute if the contract says otherwise.


Checklist for a contract with an attorney


  • It states who the client is and whom the attorney represents.

  • The immigration category and scope of services are precisely described.

  • It is clear whether a criteria strategy and evidence-gathering recommendations are included.

  • It states who prepares the forms, legal brief, recommendation letters, translations and exhibits.

  • It is clear who files the package and who pays the government fees.

  • Delivery to the client of a complete copy of the filed petition and USCIS notices is provided for.

  • It states separately whether RFE and NOID responses are included.

  • It is clear whether refiling, motions, appeals, the consular stage and I-485 are included.

  • All additional costs and the conditions for agreeing them in advance are listed.

  • The payment schedule and the calculation of refunds of the unearned portion are described.

  • Rules are set for accepting late evidence and for additional payment for substantial rework.

  • Work timelines, interim milestones and the point at which the contract is complete are set out.

  • Grounds and procedures for termination by either party are stated.

  • Notice, transfer of the client file and protection of urgent interests on termination are provided for.

  • It is clear who files the G-28, receives notices and tracks USCIS deadlines.

  • The main contact, language and communication procedure with the firm are agreed.

  • Governing law, dispute resolution, confidentiality and limitations of liability have been checked.


The main principle is simple: the contract should describe not only the payment amount but the whole path from the start of work to a specific result. The fewer vague wordings it contains, the lower the risk that client and attorney understand the scope of their cooperation differently.


This material is for general information only and does not replace a review of your specific contract by an independent attorney familiar with the rules of the state in which your representative is licensed.


Official sources

Related Posts

See All
Business Plan: Understanding the Basics

How to write a business plan for EB-2 NIW, EB-1A, EB-1C, O, L and E visas. Key sections: market analysis, project description, financial model. National importance, competitiveness, job creation. Comm

 
 
 

Comments


← Back to the knowledge base

bottom of page