top of page

← Back to the knowledge base

RFE: What It Is and How to Approach It

10 hours ago
9 min read

What is an RFE?


The talent visa process is quite complex. Some people get approved right away and then get the visa. But that is not always the case.


Sometimes the officer does not have enough evidence of your talent, or your documents are not prepared correctly. Then, instead of an approval, you get an RFE and a lot of stress on top.


An RFE, or request for evidence, is a letter USCIS sends you if the case is not prepared correctly, if the attached documents do not convey what makes you unique, or if the officer simply does not understand some details in the evidence. The letter describes in detail which criteria were accepted and which ones you “missed”.


Many people get upset when they receive such news, but in fact it is more of a plus than a minus. After all, an RFE is not a denial, but a second chance to show yourself in a better light — with hints from USCIS! Attorneys usually know how to handle such requests and will put your talent firmly on the road to the visa.


What are the possible outcomes of filing a petition?


When you file a petition with USCIS, there are four possible outcomes:

  1. approval,

  2. an RFE (Request for Evidence),

  3. a NOID (Notice of Intent to Deny)

  4. an immediate denial.


The last one is extremely rare, but it happens (0.23% of cases, to be precise, based on 2017–2023 data). An immediate denial may come if the officer finds that the petition has nothing to do with the criteria at all, not even one is formally met, and moreover the facts the applicant relies on are false. But in general, if you tell the truth, know the criteria and file the petition understanding that you need to meet three, after your first filing you will either be approved right away or get the chance to supplement your petition by responding to an RFE or NOID. As for the last option, i.e. a denial without a chance to supplement your case, you need not worry — it is an extremely rare exception.

An important USCIS rule update from August 2026

On August 5, 2026, USCIS issued Policy Alert PA-2026-05, which expands officers’ authority to deny a petition right away — without a prior RFE or NOID — if required initial evidence is missing at filing or the documents submitted do not establish eligibility for the benefit. This is a return to the policy that was in effect in 2018–2021 under the first Trump administration and a reversal of the softer approach introduced in 2021 under the Biden administration. The new rule takes effect immediately and applies to all petitions filed (or already pending) from August 5, 2026. The response deadlines have also changed: officers are no longer required to give the maximum 12 weeks for an RFE or 30 days for a NOID (these are still upper limits, but not guaranteed), and the extra 14 days for letters sent outside the US has been removed. So the stakes of the initial filing have risen significantly: you should no longer count on a “second chance” through an RFE, and the document package must be complete and convincing from the start.




What types of RFE are there?


  • RFIE (Request for Initial Evidence), or a “technical RFE”, is sent when mandatory papers from the form’s own checklist are missing at the initial filing. This usually happens when a copy of the passport or another document expressly listed in the form instructions is missing. Unlike a regular RFE, which asks for additional evidence on the merits, an RFIE concerns the basic set of documents. Also note that, unlike an RFE, which is sent after the case has been accepted for review, if you did not include, for example, the fee payment, if signatures or pages were missing from the forms, or if you used outdated forms, your case will not be accepted and will be returned to you with a description of what was missing.

  • RFE (Request for Evidence) comes later, if the officer needs to clarify facts or strengthen the evidence under the criteria. The RFE letter will state how much time you have to respond.


The key difference between them is when the request is sent and how much material is missing. USCIS gives the same window: a maximum of 12 weeks, plus 3 days for mail.

Important! Under the new 2026 rules, the deadline may be shortened at the officer’s discretion. Check your specific notice. The extra 14 days for mail delivery from outside the US has also been removed.

There is also the NOID (Notice of Intent to Deny) — a warning letter: “We are ready to deny, but we are giving you a chance to object.”

  • The response deadline is up to 30 days (versus 87 calendar days for an RFE).

  • A NOID explicitly lists the reasons for the intended denial; they must be rebutted with legal arguments, not just new documents.

  • Without a response, a NOID automatically turns into a denial.


NOIDs are less common, but receiving one means the officer is already inclined to deny the case based on the existing materials. Officers often use a NOID when they agree that you formally meet the criteria but, in their view, have not proven sustained national or international acclaim at the stage of the overall analysis of all the evidence (final merits determination), as happens, for example, in EB-1A cases and less often in O-1.


What are common reasons for an RFE?


  • The criteria are not proven. For example, although you are a member of a professional association, you did not show that it admits members based on outstanding achievements.

  • 3+ criteria are proven, but your extraordinary ability and sustained acclaim are not. For example, the officer became suspicious that almost all the achievements were gathered over the past year.

  • The national importance of your project is not proven. This applies to EB-2 NIW: for example, you showed that you are a top professional, but did not explain what you will do in the US and why it is of national importance.

  • Not enough evidence from independent sources. Say you took information about an award only from the official website, without backing it up with independent coverage from the media or the professional community.

  • A translation of documents is missing, incomplete or does not meet translation requirements.

  • Links in the petition lead to pages that do not exist.

  • And so on. In fact there are many reasons — it depends on the visa category, the criteria being claimed, etc.


In what form will I receive an RFE?


The RFE is sent to the mailing address you listed in your petition. An RFE corresponds to Form i-797E. So if your address has changed, you need to update it in your USCIS online account. You can do this at this link.


What to expect after responding to an RFE?


After you respond to an RFE, there may again be three options: approval, denial or... another RFE. Sometimes the first one is a so-called “technical RFE”, which concerns not the criteria but a missing important document. Then you send that document, and after that everything proceeds as usual: approval or a classic RFE analyzing the criteria you did not meet.


After you respond to an RFE on the criteria, there are only two possible outcomes: approval or denial. If denied, you can either refile the petition or file an appeal.


Where can you read official information about RFEs?


Official information about Requests for Evidence is available at this link.


Can you send documents to USCIS after filing the petition if you forgot something and do not want an RFE?


USCIS advises that you cannot — until they ask themselves. If you have already sent the petition but then realized some important documents are missing, do not send them to USCIS separately on your own initiative. You will have to wait for the RFE, which will tell you what is missing. It may also turn out that the document you thought you needed to send was unnecessary.


If you did not send an important document with your petition, you may first receive a “technical” RFE requesting that document, and then an RFE analyzing the criteria (or an approval right away!). If you send a document separately, there is a high risk it will get lost.


What share of petitions get an RFE?


In the O-1 visa statistics from October 2016 to September 2023 we see the following data:

  • 75% of all applicants were approved right away, and about 24.5% more received an RFE.

  • After responding to an RFE, the average likelihood of success is 70%. So a Request for Evidence really is more like another chance to show yourself.

  • On average, 92.5% of those who filed Form I-129 in this category were approved (with or without an RFE).

  • Only about two-tenths of a percent (0.23%) were denied outright without a request for evidence (which shows how rare that is).



Is it true that premium processing increases the likelihood of an RFE?


In short, no. RFEs are issued on both premium and standard processing petitions, and there is no direct link between an RFE and the type of processing.


The review does not increase the likelihood of an RFE when the criteria are strong and the petition is written in as much detail as possible, but nobody can completely rule out a request for more evidence.


What does an RFE look like?


An RFE can be divided into 4 logical parts:

  1. Which law applies. This part is fairly standard and does not matter much for the response.

  2. What evidence you have already provided. Check this list carefully, because USCIS may have missed some documents you already sent. In that case, resubmit the requested documents.

  3. What evidence you need to provide. The largest section. We recommend making a list of what is being requested and, if possible, attaching as many documents from this list as you can to your RFE response.

  4. The deadline for responding and where to send it. Remember this date — the USCIS office must have received your response by then. Received, that is — sending your response on the last day will not do.


The USCIS website has various templates for Requests for Evidence:

You can use these templates to learn the key points USCIS officers pay attention to when reviewing a petition.


What to do after receiving an RFE?


  1. Stay calm. You have another chance to respond. An RFE and even a NOID are not yet a denial. Think about whether you want to respond to the RFE yourself or go to an attorney.

  2. Make a copy of the RFE, as the original will need to be sent back to USCIS.

  3. Read the RFE text carefully — better yet, several times. You need to understand exactly what is being asked of you. Make a list of the documents you need to provide.

  4. Check whether there are documents you already provided that USCIS did not see and did not mention in the RFE. They will need to be sent again in the requested format.

  5. Gather the missing documents. It is better to start as early as possible.

  6. Prepare the document package. The first page should be the original of your RFE. Then comes a cover letter describing the evidence provided. And finally all the documents you have gathered.

  7. Mail the documents to the address in your RFE. Remember that USCIS must already have received (!) your documents by the response deadline.


What if some of the requested documents do not exist?


In this case you can provide a partial response. Try to gather as much as you can. For the missing documents, attach an explanation of why they are not available, or explain how the other documents provided answer the request.

As a last resort, you can withdraw the application and refile the petition, but that will cost the same as a new filing. Fees for the previous filing will not be refunded.


Is it better to respond to an RFE yourself or with an attorney?


Often even those who filed the petition themselves go to an attorney at the RFE stage. First, an RFE response usually costs much less than writing a full petition with an attorney. Second, if after the initial filing you have another chance in the form of an RFE, after the RFE the decision is final. So if you get a complex RFE and are not confident you can respond convincingly, it is recommended to see an attorney.


What happens if you do not respond to an RFE at all?


If you do not respond to the RFE by the date stated in the request, USCIS will deny your petition. If you want to avoid a denial, you can write to USCIS and withdraw your application yourself.


Note that refiling will be expensive, while the RFE is “included in the price” of the initial filing. However, if you realize that your case is weak at this stage, the best decision may be to withdraw the petition so that there is no denial in your immigration history, and refile once you have gathered strong evidence.


Related Posts

See All

Comments


← Back to the knowledge base

bottom of page