A Business Plan for EB-2 NIW, and Why It Is Not Scary
The most common question asked by people who need to prepare a business plan for their EB-2 NIW petition is “Will my project or company fit the visa criteria? Will my idea “work” for “National Importance” and “Substantial Merit”?”
Indeed, national importance and substantial merit sound quite ambitious and at first glance intimidating. The first thought that comes to mind is “well, at the very least I have to build a factory, create Facebook from scratch, or at worst launch a rocket to Mars (and so on, as far as your imagination goes)”.
You do not need to build a factory, a social network, Microsoft Office or even Linux from scratch. For those who are ready to invest in the US economy, there are other types of visas.
In this article you will learn why a business plan is needed for a visa at all — both immigrant (all types of employment-based immigration) and nonimmigrant, such as the E-2 Treaty Investor visa.
The business plan as a product
Let’s look at your future business plan as a product through the eyes of different people — a startup founder, a product manager, a marketer and an immigration officer — because every product or service has its own target audience.
When I was looking for an investor to fund my startup, the prospective investor was interested in
Total Addressable Market (TAM), Serviceable Addressable Market (SAM) and Serviceable Obtainable Market (SOM), the number of users, how fast the subscriber base would grow, what promotional activities I would run, how they would help attract the target audience, what revenue I expected, at what EBITDA multiple they could potentially exit, and so on.
I, on the other hand, was interested in the rate and obligations under which I could raise this round. Things were complicated by the fact that the investor was from my industry, understood what I was doing, asked the right questions and, naturally, demanded a report on what the money was spent on and how effectively, because the funding agreement gave the investor that right. By the way, any investor will come to your rescue as soon as you have revenue.
“But what does an immigration officer have to do with this?” you may reasonably ask. Here is what: this person is not a finance expert and acts within their authority and instructions. So save your three-, four- and more-letter words like TAM, SAM, SOM and — dare I say it — EBITDA, EBIT and OIBDA for your professional communities.• And as for your EBITDA multiple … well, you know where to put it.
Moreover, the USCIS Policy Manual states that “many innovations and entrepreneurial endeavors may ultimately fail, in whole or in part, despite an intelligent plan and competent execution”. The decision does not require applicants “to demonstrate that their endeavors are more likely than not to ultimately succeed”.
A business plan for a petition: what should it contain?
“And how does all this — blah blah blah — said above bring me closer to writing a business plan that meets the petition requirements?” you may ask.
For an immigration officer to be able to make a favorable decision for you without any risk to themselves, the business plan must demonstrate the quantitative and qualitative indicators of your business venture. By the way, our expertise in a particular industry often plays a cruel joke on us — we think everyone understands when we start using industry abbreviations and terms.
Here is what a business plan should contain:
Market analysis
A description of the target audience/potential customers of the new commercial enterprise
The business’s marketing strategy, including pricing, advertising and service
Sales, cost and revenue projections with the underlying data
The plan should present the organizational structure of the business and the experience of its staff
If needed, it should describe the production process, required materials and sources of supply (if applicable)
If needed, the plan should describe in detail any contracts signed for the supply of materials and/or distribution of products (if applicable)
In fact, if you open any textbook on writing business plans, you will find all of these sections, because every business is created to make a profit, unless it is a not-for-profit organization.
“So where do I come in?” the reader may ask.
Here is where: you are setting out on a very important path of changing your life by changing your immigration status, and you are the main character of this story — part of which is your business plan, describing the essence of your venture. You have a unique set of knowledge, skills and abilities that will be the foundation for carrying out your project. Your story should be told accordingly in the product I mentioned at the very beginning — the business plan.
Venture capitalist vs USCIS officer
Now you may ask: how are a venture capitalist and the immigration officer who will read your business plan connected?
The answer: their interests are completely opposite.
A venture capitalist is interested only in revenue and profit, and staff costs, by the way, reduce that profit. People tend to get sick, burn out and change jobs, and it would be better if robots came to work instead, did not need medical care and generally stayed out of the way.
An immigration officer, on the contrary, is interested in how many jobs your business can create for US residents, how the benefit of your venture can reach as many people as possible, what exactly your product or service will make easier for people, and how it will improve their quality of life.
All because their instructions say that their task is to improve the situation of US residents, in particular through creating new jobs. By the way, I do not recommend using a shortage of qualified workers in your industry to justify the value of your project or venture, because that issue is handled by a different government body — the US Department of Labor.
And finally, you need to learn two important words — “feasible” and “credible”. These are also requirements for the business plan, meaning it must be achievable and believable. If you “draw” 100 jobs, you must be ready to answer where the money to fund those jobs will come from.
How to create a business plan
So what should you do? How do you create a business plan that is realistic and at the same time convinces the officer reading your petition?
You can figure everything out yourself using literature on business plan writing or ChatGPT. But keep in mind that ChatGPT is not the place that will tell you about the country’s priorities, immigration law, international politics and other aspects that matter to you. Or you can get help from an expert.
In this case, I will be happy to help you prepare a business plan that will not only contain the required sections on marketing, the market and financial projections (which, by the way, is the easiest section for those familiar with financial modeling and the key growth drivers in their industry), but will also be “feasible” and “credible”. I have not only extensive experience working with bureaucratic structures at the international level, which helps translate from “bureaucratese” into plain language, but also experience in organizational design, HR management, corporate governance, regulatory drafting, marketing, sales, product development and financial modeling.

Comments