Requests for Evidence (RFE) on EB-2 NIW Petitions: Main Reasons and How to Avoid Them
The EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW) category is an attractive path to a green card for people whose work can bring significant benefit to the United States. However, over the past couple of years, the number of Requests for Evidence (RFEs) on these petitions has risen noticeably.
Below is an analysis of mistakes that come up often, especially for applicants who filed on their own or used template business plans. These mistakes are often linked not only to an underdeveloped core case strategy, but also to a misunderstanding of the EB-2 NIW criteria themselves.
1. No clear plan of work in the US (proposed endeavor)
This is one of the main reasons for an RFE. An EB-2 NIW case must clearly describe the intended projects and plan of work in the US. Many applicants describe their past achievements in detail — as they would for EB-1 — but do not say what exactly they will do in the US in the future.
USCIS is interested not only in your experience and qualifications (although they matter), but also in how exactly your work will benefit the US — in the economy, healthcare, education and other areas.
You need to present the project clearly: its goal, implementation timeline, financial feasibility, expected impact and scale.
2. Insufficient justification of the national importance of the project itself
It is not enough to simply state that the industry (for example, healthcare or education) is important. You need to explain why your specific work matters to the country — how it solves a critical problem or meets a national need. Without such justification, the petition often gets an RFE.
3. Shifting the focus from the project to the industry
A common mistake in applications is emphasizing the importance of the whole industry (for example, the environment or healthcare) without explaining how exactly your specific project is different and how it addresses a national need.
USCIS requires you to show that the applicant’s contribution is unique, significant and in the interest of the US. Your specific work and its impact on the industry are what should be at the center of the case.
What matters is not so much how important the industry is on paper, but what specific role and actions you will take to make a real, measurable impact.
You need to clearly convey how exactly your project will be implemented, not just describe the idea. This includes the key elements: how the project will be funded and what steps you will take to make it succeed. A convincing position is important, but implementation is what decides it , along with the steps you have already taken.
4. Misunderstanding the term “national importance”
Many applicants mistakenly believe that paying taxes or creating jobs in itself means national importance. However, USCIS sees these as ordinary aspects of any business.
To succeed, you need to answer the key question: What do you actually want to achieve? What practical benefit will your work bring not only to the industry, but to society as a whole?
If your project is local, it is hard to show national importance. One recommendation here is to focus on how your work in targeted employment areas (TEAs) benefits economically disadvantaged areas and aligns with broader national interests.
National importance means the project:
solves a major problem;
has a systemic impact;
creates a significant number of jobs;
has the potential to expand beyond the local level.
Examples of mistakes:
the project is limited to the local level, and it is not shown how it affects national interests;
the materials do not demonstrate impact on key areas such as technology, medicine or education;
the statistics and publications are general and not connected to the applicant’s work;
even if the project involves hiring several employees, this is not enough without evidence of a broader social or economic effect.
5. Contribution to the industry and field is not sufficiently proven
Unlike EB-1 cases, in EB-2 NIW petitions it is extremely important to show the applicant’s contribution to the development of the industry. This can be a track record of successful projects, research results, recognition from peers, ideas put into practice or products developed. This is critical if you want to prove that your future project will benefit the US.
You need to strategically connect past achievements with future impact and use statistics and measurable results to justify the national importance of your future work.
By showing that you have already made an impact in your field, you strengthen the argument that you will continue this work in the US with similar success.
6. Weak or missing financial calculations
If the project involves investment or entrepreneurship, you need to show that it is financially realistic and sustainable. Failing to explain the source of funding, the cost structure and projected results makes USCIS doubt that the project can be carried out.
The presentation should include clear financial projections and evidence that funds are available.
7. Insufficient entrepreneurial experience
If you plan to carry out the project in the US as a business, it is important to show that you already have successful experience in this area.
If you describe opening a company in the US, you need to show that you have already taken steps in this direction — for example, registered the business, contributed capital, received business letters or signed contracts.
If you plan to run the same type of business as abroad and have already been successful there, it is important to prove that success with objective evidence, to justify that further development of the project in the US is realistic.
If you do not have entrepreneurial experience, it may be wise to bring in a partner with a relevant business background.
USCIS regularly states that the materials submitted do not confirm the applicant’s ability to carry out the proposed endeavor if:
there is no evidence that the applicant has previously created or successfully managed a similar business;
no contracts, agreements or other documents confirming progress in implementing the project are submitted;
recommendation letters do not contain specific examples of achievements or objective metrics of success;
the applicant’s résumé, education and experience do not confirm the necessary skills or industry reputation to carry out the project in the US.
8. An unsuitable or underdeveloped project
Sometimes the very nature of the proposed project does not meet EB-2 NIW requirements. For example, opening a store, café or import business without convincing evidence of national importance will almost certainly be denied.
If the project does not involve solving a significant problem or has no systemic effect — it is not suitable for EB-2 NIW.
Conclusion
The growing number of RFEs highlights the need for a competently and strategically prepared case. Many applicants seek professional help only after receiving an RFE, when time and resources have already been spent.
It is important to assess your chances and work out a strategy before filing, in order to:
increase the likelihood of approval;
avoid the costs of reworking the case;
not waste resources on projects that are weak from the start.

Comments