Judging the Work of Others: The Criterion for EB‑1A and O‑1
Serving on a jury, an expert panel or in professional peer review can be used as one of the evidentiary criteria in EB‑1A and O‑1A petitions. USCIS evaluates not just the name of the role — “judge,” “jury member,” “expert” or “reviewer” — but whether the applicant actually evaluated the work of others, whether that work was in their professional or an allied field, and whether their actual participation is documented.
This criterion often seems simple: get an invitation to a jury and attach a certificate. In practice, a strong package needs to answer several questions at once: who chose the applicant and why, what exactly they evaluated, under what rules, whether they completed the evaluation, who the participants were and what significance the applicant’s expert role had.
Neither EB‑1A nor O‑1A is approved just because one criterion is formally met. Judging is considered together with the rest of the evidence and should help show the applicant’s broader professional recognition.
This material is for information only and is not a substitute for an immigration attorney’s analysis of a specific petition.
Which categories the criterion applies to
Category | How judging is used |
EB‑1A | One of ten regulatory criteria. If the applicant does not have a one-time achievement on the level of a major internationally recognized award, they usually need to meet at least three criteria and then pass a final assessment of all the evidence. |
O‑1A | One of eight regulatory criteria for the sciences, education, business and athletics. Absent a major internationally recognized award, at least three criteria usually need to be met, after which USCIS evaluates the evidence as a whole. |
EB‑1B | A similar criterion also exists for outstanding professors and researchers: participation in judging the work of others in the same or an allied academic field. However, EB‑1B has a separate set of requirements and is not the subject of this article. |
O‑1B | The direct list of O‑1B criteria for the arts, motion pictures and television has no separate judging criterion. In some cases, such activity is presented as comparable evidence if the regulatory criteria do not readily apply to the specific occupation. This is not an automatic transfer of the O‑1A criterion: you need to explain separately which criterion is being replaced, why it does not fit the occupation and how judging is comparable to it. |
For most professionals who talk about the “judging criterion” in relation to O‑1, it is O‑1A that is meant. For creative professionals, judging can be used directly in EB‑1A, but in O‑1B its procedural role is different.
Official wording
For EB‑1A, the regulation requires evidence of the applicant’s participation, either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of specialization for which classification is sought. The wording is found in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv).
O‑1A uses essentially the same construction: evidence of the beneficiary’s participation on a panel or individually as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of specialization. The requirement is in 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B).
The USCIS Policy Manual on EB‑1A and the USCIS Policy Manual on O‑1 clarify a crucial point: you need to prove not only an invitation to judge the work of others, but also actual participation in the judging.
What exactly needs to be proven
It is convenient to split the criterion into four elements.
1. The applicant served as a judge or expert
The title alone does not settle the question. USCIS is interested in the substance of the function: the applicant must have analyzed, compared, evaluated or selected the work of others and influenced a professional decision.
A qualifying role may be called different things:
jury member;
competition judge;
expert or expert assessor;
reviewer for a scientific journal;
reviewer or peer reviewer;
member of a grant, certification or dissertation committee;
member of a selection committee;
expert for an award, accelerator, festival, championship or professional competition.
What matters is not the word on the certificate but the proven nature of the work. For example, “organizing committee member” does not necessarily mean judging: an organizing committee may handle the program, logistics or promotion. Likewise, a “mentor” may advise participants without making evaluation or selection decisions.
2. The work of others was evaluated
The subject of evaluation must be the work, result, project, research, application, performance, product or professional qualifications of other people.
This may include:
scientific articles, abstracts and papers;
applications for research grants;
dissertations and other final research works;
business projects, strategies, financial models and startup pitches;
software products, engineering solutions and competition entries;
architectural, design, artistic and media projects;
performances, athletic results, culinary entries or other competition pieces;
candidates for a professional award, scholarship, residency or place in a program.
An administrative check of whether documents are complete, technical verification of an application form or mechanically assigning scores without professional judgment may not show genuine judging. The package should explain what expert judgment was required of the applicant.
3. The work was in the same or an allied field
The judging must be connected to the field in which the applicant is proving extraordinary ability. The job titles do not have to match exactly: the regulation allows an allied field. But the connection must be clear and verifiable.
For example:
a machine learning specialist reviews articles on computer vision;
a product leader evaluates tech startups and product strategies;
an architect sits on the jury of an urban environment competition;
a pastry chef judges entries at a professional pastry championship;
a marketing specialist evaluates advertising campaigns for an industry award;
an athlete or coach judges competitions in their own or a closely related sport.
If the connection is not obvious, it should be explained in the petition letter and supported by descriptions of the industries, the applicant’s duties, the competition’s subject and the evaluation criteria.
4. The applicant actually completed the evaluation
An invitation shows that the organizer wanted to bring in the specialist, but does not prove that they took part. So an invitation should ideally be combined with one or more documents showing completed work:
the submitted review;
confirmation from the editorial or competition system;
a completed evaluation sheet;
the meeting minutes;
a letter confirming completion of the work;
a letter of thanks or a jury member certificate;
the published jury list and event results;
a letter from the organizer describing in detail the duties performed.
This is one of the main practical principles: an invitation plus confirmation of completion is stronger than an invitation without a result.
How USCIS evaluates the criterion: two levels of analysis
First level: is the literal wording of the criterion met
At the first stage, USCIS decides whether the documents show that the applicant actually participated, individually or on a panel, in judging the work of others in the same or an allied field.
At this level, the regulation does not set:
a minimum number of judging engagements;
a requirement that the competition have international status;
a requirement that the judging be unpaid;
a requirement that it take place outside the applicant’s regular job;
a requirement that those evaluated hold the same or a higher rank;
a requirement that the applicant make the decision alone;
a requirement that the event be held in the US.
So the advice “you need at least three judging engagements” cannot be treated as an official rule. In principle, a single episode may be enough for the literal criterion if it is fully and convincingly documented. Several independent episodes can make the evidence more reliable and more useful at the final stage, but USCIS has set no numerical minimum.
Second level: what judging says about professional recognition
Formally meeting three criteria does not end the EB‑1A or O‑1A analysis. USCIS evaluates the whole package and determines whether the applicant really meets the high standard of the relevant category.
At this stage, the following may matter:
the reputation of the organizer, journal, award or competition;
the scale and geography of the event;
the professional level of the participants;
how competitive the selection of entries was;
the criteria for selecting judges;
why the applicant specifically was invited;
the number and complexity of works evaluated;
repeat invitations;
the applicant’s role in the final decision;
the prominence of the other jury members;
the organizer’s independence from the applicant;
the consistency of judging with other evidence of recognition.
For example, a single completed review may literally meet the criterion. But a series of reviews for authoritative journals, especially if the editor explains that reviewers are selected for their expertise and publication record, usually shows sustained professional recognition better.
Examples of judging expressly named by USCIS
The USCIS Policy Manual on EB‑1A gives a non-exhaustive list of examples:
peer reviewing for a scholarly journal — with a request from the editors and confirmation of the completed review;
evaluating abstracts or papers submitted for presentation at a scholarly conference;
serving on a dissertation committee that makes the final decision on whether the work meets the requirements for a doctoral degree;
reviewing applications in a government research funding program.
These are examples, not a closed list. Other forms of expert evaluation may also qualify if the core elements of the criterion are met.
Which activities may qualify
Science and academia
The clearest formats are peer review of scientific articles, review of conference materials, evaluation of grant applications and service on dissertation committees.
Example. A biologist received a request from a journal to review an article, accepted it, submitted a detailed review and received confirmation from the editors. The package can include the invitation letter, the completed status in the editorial system, an anonymized first page of the review, information about the journal and a letter from the editor on how reviewers are selected.
If peer review is confidential, there is no need to disclose the manuscript or the authors’ personal data. What matters is showing the fact, date, subject and completion of the work as fully as the journal’s rules allow.
Conferences and professional programs
Evaluating abstracts, papers, posters, participation applications, scholarships, industry cases or candidates for a professional award may qualify.
Example. An engineer evaluated 18 submissions to an international technical conference on a set scale — novelty, applicability and quality of methodology. A strong package will show the engineer’s appointment as a reviewer, the evaluation criteria, confirmation of the submitted scores and a letter from the program chair.
Business and entrepreneurship
In business, judging can include expert evaluation of startups, investor pitches, business plans, accelerator applications, industry awards, marketing campaigns or management projects.
Example. The founder of a tech company joined an accelerator jury and evaluated each project’s product, market, team and financial model. For the criterion, what matters is not only a page with the accelerator’s logo and a photo from the event, but also the selection rules, the jury list, proof of the scores given and an explanation of why the entrepreneur was chosen as an expert.
A manager’s ordinary hiring decision or annual review of subordinates is weaker: it may be seen as a standard management function rather than external professional recognition. Such evidence requires an especially clear explanation of the independent expert nature of the evaluation.
Technology and engineering
Possible formats include a hackathon jury, evaluation of engineering projects, a software solutions competition, selecting applications for a technical program, an industry award panel or a formal review of independent technical proposals.
Example. A cybersecurity specialist judged hackathon teams on originality of method, robustness of protection and practical applicability. The package can include the rules, the scoring matrix, the list of teams, the public jury page, a letter from the organizer and proof that scores were submitted.
Ordinary code review within one’s own team should not automatically be treated as judging. For such evidence to stand a chance, you need to show that it was not everyday collaborative code editing but formalized professional evaluation of other specialists’ independent work with real consequences for selection, acceptance or awards.
Art, design, fashion, architecture and media
For EB‑1A, juries of exhibitions, festivals, design and architecture competitions, awards, castings or professional selections may qualify.
Example. An art director evaluated entries for an industry design award on originality, visual concept and quality of execution. It is useful to show not only jury participation, but also the award’s status, the procedure for selecting experts, the number of entries and proof of completed voting.
For O‑1B, judging is not a separate direct criterion. If you plan to use it as comparable evidence, the argument must be built under the comparable evidence rules, not as an ordinary O‑1A criterion.
Athletics
Judging competitions, selecting athletes or evaluating professional performances may qualify for EB‑1A or O‑1A if the applicant actually applied expert criteria in the same or an allied sport.
Example. A national-level coach was an official judge at a championship, gave scores under the federation’s rules and signed the final results. The package can include the appointment, the judge’s license or qualifications, the competition rules, the results and information on the championship’s status.
Simply being part of a delegation, organizational work or accompanying a team is not judging.
Education and professional certification
Serving on an independent certification committee, evaluating competitive research projects, professional certification of candidates or the final assessment of dissertations may qualify.
Ordinary grading of one’s own students’ homework is not prohibited by any specific rule, but often has limited evidentiary weight. It may look like a teacher’s standard duty and does not necessarily show that the professional community chose them to evaluate specialists. The more independent, final and expert the committee, the clearer the connection to the criterion.
What often does not work or requires additional explanation
An invitation without confirmation of participation
A letter saying “we invite you to be a judge” proves the invitation, not completed work. If the applicant accepted the invitation but did not evaluate a single entry, the criterion is usually not met.
A certificate without a description of duties
A one-line certificate “for serving on the jury” is useful, but may not show what was evaluated, when the event took place, who participated and what exactly the applicant did. It is best supplemented with the rules, minutes, evaluation sheets and a letter from the organizer.
An organizational or advisory role
A speaker, mentor, moderator, curator, organizer or advisory board member is not necessarily a judge. If a person gave advice, gave a lecture or coordinated an event but did not evaluate the work of others, it is risky to count this activity toward the criterion.
Evaluating one’s own employees
A manager regularly evaluates the team’s results. This may be genuine professional analysis, but an ordinary HR function often does little to show external recognition. You need to distinguish an internal performance review from independent expert selection or formal certification.
Formal status without a real contribution
Having your name published on a jury page does not replace proof of work performed. USCIS may cross-check dates, public materials, letters and results, so the package must be internally consistent.
An event created mainly as immigration evidence
A competition without a clear history, real participants, transparent rules and an independent organizer may raise questions about the credibility and weight of the evidence. USCIS evaluates evidence as a whole, not just the look of a certificate.
The field being judged is unrelated to the stated field
A finance expert who judged an amateur literary competition does not automatically show recognition in finance. If the event is interdisciplinary, you need to describe precisely which part of the work the applicant evaluated and why it falls within their expertise.
How to gather evidence: a step-by-step system
What works best is not one document but a consistent chain: selection of the expert → evaluation rules → actual work → result → professional context.
Step 1. Document the invitation or appointment
Keep:
the official letter or email invitation;
the order, decision, contract or letter of appointment;
the message accepting the invitation;
the event page listing the jury;
the applicant’s profile on the organizer’s website.
Ideally, the document should contain the applicant’s name, the role, the name of the event or journal, the date and the subject of evaluation.
Step 2. Confirm the actual work
Gather documents showing that the evaluation was completed:
letters acknowledging receipt of the review;
screenshots from the system showing completed or submitted status;
anonymized evaluation forms;
tables of scores given;
meeting minutes;
letters with voting results;
certificates and letters of thanks after the event;
confirmation from the organizer of the number of works evaluated;
public results listing the jury.
If there are several documents, it helps to arrange them chronologically: invitation, acceptance, performance, confirmation of completion.
Step 3. Show the content and level of the works evaluated
It should be clear to USCIS that the applicant applied professional judgment rather than performing a technical check.
Where possible, attach:
the competition regulations;
the evaluation criteria and scale;
a description of the categories;
the requirements for participants;
the conference program;
anonymized information on the types of projects;
data on the number of submissions and selection stages;
the rules for making the final decision.
Step 4. Prove the connection to the applicant’s field
The connection is often obvious to a specialist, but it is better to explain it directly to the officer.
You can use:
a brief description of the professional field in the petition letter;
the applicant’s résumé and bio;
job duties;
publications, projects and awards on the same subject;
a description of the subject of the journal, competition or grant program;
a letter from the organizer on what expertise was needed from the applicant.
Do not stop at the phrase “the fields are allied.” Name the overlap: methods, market, type of product, audience, technology or professional competencies.
Step 5. Explain why the applicant specifically was chosen
For the literal criterion, the rules do not require proof of prestigious judge selection. But this explanation can significantly strengthen the overall weight of the evidence.
Information that judges are selected based on the following is useful:
experience and seniority;
publications and citations;
industry achievements;
professional awards;
completed projects;
certification or a judging license;
an independent reputation in the industry.
General compliments like “an outstanding professional” are less convincing than a specific explanation: which of the applicant’s achievements the organizer knew about and why they mattered for the evaluation.
Step 6. Show the reputation and scale of the venue
For the final analysis, gather context:
the history of the event or publication;
the official website and information about the organizer;
the geography and number of participants;
how competitive the selection is;
well-known jury members;
professional partners;
government or industry accreditation, if any;
independent publications about the event;
audience, circulation or reach, if the figures come from a reliable source.
Do not call an event “international” just because the page has an English version. Show actual participation by representatives of several countries or other verifiable grounds.
Step 7. Prepare a letter from the organizer
A letter is not required if actual participation is already reliably documented. But it is especially useful when the information is spread across different systems, confidential or unpublished.
A good letter contains:
the author’s full name and position;
information about the organization;
the name and dates of the event or process;
the applicant’s exact role;
a description of the works evaluated;
the evaluation criteria;
the number of works or rounds evaluated;
confirmation that the applicant completed the evaluation;
how the scores influenced the selection or outcome;
the criteria for selecting judges;
the specific reason the applicant was chosen;
the author’s contact details.
The letter should confirm facts, not replace all other evidence. Where possible, attach independent documents consistent with its content.
Sample structure of a supporting letter
Below is not a mandatory USCIS form but a working structure that can be adapted to the actual circumstances.
I, [name and position], represent [organization]. [Organization] runs [name of event/program] and can be briefly described as follows: [verifiable information].[Applicant’s name] was selected as [an individual expert/jury member/reviewer] for [event or period]. Judges are selected based on [specific requirements]. We invited [name] because of [specific achievements and relevant expertise].In this role, [name] evaluated [number and type of works] in the field of [subject] against the criteria [list]. [Name] completed the evaluation on [date or period], submitting [scores, reviews, recommendations]. These evaluations were used for [selecting finalists, publication decisions, awarding grants, choosing winners].I confirm that [name] actually participated in evaluating the work of others, and was not merely invited or listed as a member of the panel.
Every statement must match the actual documents. Do not ask the author to sign exaggerated or unverifiable wording.
How to handle confidential materials
Scientific journals, grant programs, employers and competition platforms may prohibit disclosure of participants’ work. Confidentiality does not mean the criterion cannot be proven.
Possible solutions:
redact the author’s name, the title of unpublished work and other sensitive data;
leave visible the reviewer’s name, date, journal or program, status and assignment ID;
attach a letter from the editor or program administrator;
show a screenshot of the account dashboard with completed assignments;
attach the confidentiality rules and explain the redactions made;
use an anonymized first page of the evaluation form;
submit an aggregated report on the number of reviews completed.
Redactions should be minimal and clear. It is useful to note what information was hidden and why. You must not change the content of a document in a way that creates a false impression of the applicant’s role.
How to present electronic evidence
For emails and web pages, it is useful to keep more context than a single clipped fragment:
the sender’s name and address;
the date;
the subject line;
the body of the message;
the platform name;
the URL and access date for a public page;
several related screens, if one screenshot does not show the whole process.
If an email contains only an automatic “thank you,” attach documents linking it to a specific completed review or evaluation.
Translating documents
Documents not in English must be accompanied by a complete English translation and the translator’s certificate stating that the translation is complete and accurate and that they are competent to translate from that language. This rule is set out in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3) and in the USCIS checklist for Form I‑140.
Translate not only the certificate but also significant text on stamps, screenshots, competition pages, minutes and letters. If one exhibit contains many similar pages, plan convenient numbering of originals and translations in advance.
How to assemble the petition section
One convenient way to organize the exhibits:
A brief legal explanation of the criterion. State the category, the regulatory wording and the four facts: the role, the work of others, the connection between fields and actual participation.
A summary table of episodes. For each episode, list the organizer, date, type of works, number of entries evaluated and exhibit numbers.
Invitation or appointment. Show how the applicant got the role.
Evidence of performance. Reviews, scores, minutes, system confirmations and closing letters.
Rules and subject of evaluation. Regulations, criteria, a description of participants and works.
Connection to the field. A brief explanation of why the works evaluated belong to the same or an allied specialization.
Judge selection and the reason for the invitation. The organizer’s rules and a supporting letter.
Reputation and scale. Official and independent materials about the journal, competition or organization.
Translations. Complete translations and the translator’s certificate.
It is best to present each episode as a complete story rather than putting all invitations in one section, all certificates in another and all screenshots in a third. It should be easy for the officer to match the documents.
Practical examples analyzed
Example 1. A scientist completed one article review
Evidence: the journal’s invitation, the accepted review, a screenshot of the completed status, information about the journal’s subject area.
Preliminary assessment: may be enough to meet the literal criterion if it is clear that the scientist actually evaluated scientific work in their own or an allied field. For the final assessment, it is useful to add the reviewer selection criteria, the journal’s reputation and other reviews, if any.
Example 2. An entrepreneur is listed on a startup competition jury
Evidence: a public page listing the jury and a photo from the event.
Problem: the documents show presence and the claimed role but may not confirm actual evaluation.
What to add: a letter from the organizer, the evaluation criteria, a score table, minutes, the number of projects reviewed and the competition results.
Example 3. A teacher grades their own students’ exams
Evidence: a job description and grade sheets.
Preliminary assessment: this does involve evaluating the work of others, but may look like a routine teaching duty with limited evidentiary weight. An independent state certification, dissertation or competition committee to which the teacher was chosen for their expertise would be stronger.
Example 4. A manager took part in selecting employees
Evidence: interviews, scorecards and the hiring decision.
Preliminary assessment: candidates were evaluated, but it is not always clear whether their professional work was the subject and whether the selection showed the applicant’s recognition in the industry. Such an episode requires careful argument and is usually weaker than an independent industry jury.
Example 5. A designer judged a professional award
Evidence: the appointment, the award rules, the list of categories, the submitted scores, the results and a letter from the jury chair.
Preliminary assessment: for EB‑1A this may be strong evidence, especially if the award has a documented reputation and judges are selected for their achievements. For O‑1B, it cannot simply be called one of the direct criteria; possible use as comparable evidence requires separate analysis.
Example 6. An expert received three certificates from little-known online competitions
Evidence: certificates without rules, works or results.
Preliminary assessment: the number of certificates does not make up for the lack of evidence of actual participation and professional context. One well-documented real competition may be more convincing than three token certificates.
How many judging engagements are needed
USCIS does not set a minimum number of episodes for this criterion. There is no official rule of “three competitions,” “five reviews” or “ten works evaluated.”
The practical question has two parts:
Is there enough evidence to show at least one actual judging engagement?
How much does this activity help show the applicant’s sustained acclaim at the final stage?
One prestigious and well-documented appointment may be more significant than a series of random invitations. On the other hand, repeated independent invitations from several authoritative sources can show that the professional community consistently trusts the applicant to evaluate others’ work.
So the sensible goal is not to collect an arbitrary number of certificates, but to assemble a sufficient body of quality evidence.
Do the professionals evaluated have to be at the applicant’s level
The regulatory wording speaks of the work of others, not only of peers of equal status. It does not set a formal requirement that participants hold the same or a higher position.
However, the level of the participants affects the context and evidentiary weight. Evaluating the work of recognized professionals, research proposals, professional projects or finalists of an industry competition usually demonstrates trust in the applicant’s expertise better than routine grading of beginning students’ assignments.
The main question is not rank as such, but whether this was genuine professional evaluation in the same or an allied field and what the appointment says about the applicant’s recognition.
Can judging done as part of one’s regular job be used
The regulations have no automatic prohibition on judging performed as part of job duties or for payment. Such participation may meet the literal criterion.
But an ordinary duty may carry less weight in the overall analysis if the documents do not show special selection, independence or professional recognition. So it is important to explain:
why this function required high expertise;
who was entitled to perform it;
how the applicant was chosen;
which decisions depended on their evaluation;
why the work evaluated belonged to the stated field.
Can judging be done online or outside the US
Yes. The wording of the criterion does not restrict the format of the event or the country where it takes place. Online journal reviewing, remote jury voting or evaluation of international applications can be used in the same way as in-person participation, if the documents confirm actual work.
The location does not replace evidence of quality. An organizer’s US address alone does not make judging strong, and an event outside the US does not make it weak.
Does the judging have to take place before filing
The petitioner must show eligibility for the requested classification as of the filing date. So to include judging in the initial count of criteria, it is safer to rely on evaluation actually completed before the petition is filed, not on a future invitation.
An invitation to an event after the filing date may support continued recognition in a broader sense, but should not be used to substitute for a fact that did not exist on the filing date. The general principle of eligibility at filing is set out in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1).
How to strengthen the criterion before filing
Look for real expert opportunities that match your professional profile, not events created only to issue certificates.
Ethical and natural routes may include:
registering as a reviewer for a journal in your field, if you have suitable qualifications;
serving on the program committee of a professional conference;
working with an industry association or professional award;
evaluating applications in an accelerator, grant program or competition;
obtaining the required license as a sports judge;
serving on an independent certification or dissertation committee;
evaluating professional projects through a recognized organization.
There is no guarantee that any role you obtain will be accepted by USCIS. What matters is the reality of the process, the match with your field, the actual work and the quality of the documentation.
Common mistakes
Attaching only the invitation. It does not confirm completed evaluation.
Attaching only the certificate. It may not reveal the substance of the role.
Not explaining the connection between fields. Especially if the competition’s name is broader than or different from the applicant’s position.
Confusing judging with mentoring, speaking or organizing. These roles may be useful for the petition but do not necessarily support this criterion.
Treating three engagements as mandatory. USCIS sets no such numerical rule.
Claiming the event is prestigious without evidence. You need verifiable facts, not the organizer’s promotional wording.
Not showing the actual work. A jury page and photos do not replace evaluation sheets, minutes or confirmation from the organizer.
Not translating small but important text. USCIS must understand the documents in full.
Presenting ordinary internal review as independent judging. Describe the context honestly and do not exaggerate the role.
Creating an inconsistent package. Dates, role names, number of works and information in letters must match.
Hiding too much in confidential documents. After redaction, enough information must remain to link the document to the applicant and the specific evaluation.
Stopping at the literal criterion. You also need to show why this judging matters in the overall picture of professional recognition.
Self-check checklist
Before filing, check each episode against the list.
The fact of the role
There is a document of invitation or appointment.
The applicant’s name, role, organization and date are stated.
It is clear that the role specifically involved evaluation.
Actual participation
There is confirmation that the applicant accepted the invitation.
There is proof of submitted scores, reviews or votes.
There is confirmation that the work was completed.
Subject of evaluation
It is clear whose work and what kind of work was evaluated.
The criteria or rules are attached.
It is evident that professional judgment was required.
Connection to the field
The work evaluated belongs to the same or an allied field.
If the connection is not obvious, it is explained and supported.
Weight of the evidence
The organizer’s reputation and activities are shown.
The criteria for selecting judges are explained.
The specific reason for choosing the applicant is stated.
The scale, level of participants and influence of the evaluations on the outcome are shown.
Presentation
All documents are legible and numbered consistently.
Foreign documents have a complete English translation and the translator’s certificate.
Confidential information is redacted minimally and explicably.
Statements in the petition letter can be verified against the exhibits.
The judging was actually completed by the filing date, if the criterion count relies on it.
FAQ
Is one judging engagement enough
There is no official minimum. One fully documented episode may meet the literal wording, but its significance in the final analysis depends on its quality, context and the rest of the evidence.
Is a jury invitation enough
No. USCIS expressly distinguishes between an invitation and actual participation. You need documents showing that the applicant actually performed the evaluation.
Is a certificate required
No. A certificate is just one possible document. An electronic system, a review, minutes, an evaluation sheet and a detailed letter from the organizer may be more informative.
Can peer review of scientific articles be used
Yes. USCIS expressly gives peer review for a scholarly journal as an example, if there is a request from the journal and confirmation of the completed review.
Can evaluating conference submissions be used
Yes. USCIS also gives evaluating abstracts and papers submitted for presentation at a scholarly conference as an example of judging.
Does a dissertation committee qualify
Yes, if the committee makes the final decision on whether the work meets the degree requirements and the applicant actually took part in that evaluation.
Does a startup competition jury qualify
It may, if the applicant evaluated real projects against professional criteria, the work is connected to their field and participation is documented.
Does mentoring qualify
Not necessarily on its own. A mentor helps participants, while a judge evaluates their work and influences the decision. If a person combined the roles, the evaluative function needs to be confirmed separately.
Does serving on a journal’s editorial board qualify
Membership on an editorial board alone does not prove completed reviewing. If the applicant actually made decisions on manuscripts or performed reviews, this needs to be confirmed separately.
Can paid judging be used
Yes, there is no direct prohibition. Payment does not cancel the criterion, but the documents must still show the expert nature and actual performance of the work.
Does online judging count
It can. The format is not decisive; what matters is the substance of the role, the connection to the field and confirmation of the completed evaluation.
Do I need to judge an international competition
No. International status is not required for the literal criterion. But the scale and reputation of the venue can affect the weight of the evidence in the overall assessment.
Can judging support other parts of the petition at the same time
Yes. For example, repeated invitations can supplement an argument about professional recognition, and a letter from the organizer can explain a contribution, reputation or leading role. However, the same document must meet the separate requirements of each claimed criterion; there is no automatic double counting.
Conclusion
For the judging criterion, what matters is proving not a formal title but completed expert work. A strong package shows that the applicant was chosen to evaluate the work of others, actually carried out the evaluation, that the subject was in the same or an allied field, and that the documents make it possible to understand the level and significance of this activity.
The most convincing materials form a continuous chain: the invitation or appointment, the rules and criteria, evidence of completed evaluation, the outcome of the process, the connection to the professional field and the context of the organizer’s reputation. At the same time, there is no official requirement of three judging engagements, mandatory international scope or equal status of the professionals evaluated.
For EB‑1A and O‑1A, meeting the criterion is only part of the analysis. The ultimate goal is for judging, together with the other evidence, to show sustained acclaim and compliance with the high standard of the chosen category.
Official sources
USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 — Extraordinary Ability (EB‑1A)
USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4 — O‑1 Beneficiaries
8 CFR 214.2 — Special requirements for admission, extension, and maintenance of status
USCIS — Checklist of Required Initial Evidence for Form I‑140
USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4 — Burden and Standards of Proof
8 CFR 103.2 — Submission and adjudication of benefit requests
Useful resources
Judging and competitions — independent competitions and awards where you can join a jury or evaluate entries.
Case resources — all the site’s resource collections, grouped by USCIS criteria.
Expert catalog — attorneys, PR specialists and case preparation assistants who can help you put together your evidence.

Comments