Why Three Criteria Are Not Enough for O-1 and EB-1A: How USCIS Evaluates the Whole Case
Simply gathering documents for three criteria is not enough to get an O-1 or EB-1A petition approved. The minimum number of criteria is only one stage of the review. After it, USCIS evaluates all the evidence together and decides whether the applicant’s professional level truly meets the requirements of the chosen category.
Let’s look at how this evaluation works, why the number of criteria does not guarantee a result, and what distinguishes a convincing case from a formally assembled set of documents.
How many criteria are required for O-1 and EB-1A
The exact requirements depend on the category and the applicant’s field.
Category | Minimum requirements |
O-1A for science, education, business and athletics | A major internationally recognized award or at least 3 of 8 criteria |
O-1B for the arts | A significant national or international award or nomination, or at least 3 of 6 criteria |
O-1B for film and television | An award or nomination of the appropriate level, or at least 3 of 6 criteria |
EB-1A | A major internationally recognized achievement or at least 3 of 10 criteria |
These requirements are set out in the regulations for O-1 and the regulations for EB-1A.
At the same time, the standards themselves differ across categories. For example, an O-1A applicant in science or business must show that they are among the small percentage who have risen to the very top of their field. O-1B in the arts uses the standard of “distinction”. For EB-1A you need to prove sustained national or international acclaim and that you are among the leading professionals in your field.
So you cannot evaluate all O-1 and EB-1A categories on one universal scale.
How USCIS reviews a petition
USCIS uses a two-step analysis of the evidence. This approach is described in detail in the Policy Manual for O-1 and the Policy Manual for EB-1A.
Step one: does the evidence meet the criteria
First, the officer checks whether each document submitted meets the requirements of the specific criterion.
For example:
for the judging criterion, you need to show not just an invitation, but actual participation in evaluating the work of others;
for high salary, you need to submit income documents and a proper comparison with the earnings of other professionals in the same field;
for a leading or critical role, what matters is not only the job title, but the nature of the work, its importance to the organization and the reputation of the organization itself;
for published material about the applicant, you need to show that the material is really about the applicant and their work and was published in professional, major trade or other major media.
At this stage you cannot simply label a document an “award”, “judging” or a “publication”. You need to prove every element set out in the regulations.
Step two: does the case show the required professional level
If the minimum number of criteria is met, USCIS considers the petition as a whole. This stage is often called the final merits determination.
The officer analyzes not only whether there are achievements, but also:
the level and scope of professional recognition;
the significance of the achievements for the field;
the independence and reliability of the sources;
the applicant’s standing compared with other professionals;
the duration and sustainability of the recognition;
whether the proposed work in the US matches the applicant’s field;
the consistency of all the documents and statements in the petition.
That is why three criteria met do not mean automatic approval. Even a larger number of criteria does not by itself guarantee the result.
Why a formally met criterion may not be convincing enough
The same document can carry different weight at the first and second steps of the review.
Authorship of professional articles
At the first step, articles can help confirm authorship of professional or scholarly material. During the final merits determination, USCIS may also consider the impact of the publications: the authority of the outlet, citations, use of the results by other professionals and the significance of the work for the field.
Having an article and proving significant professional impact are not the same thing.
Judging
Serving on a jury or as a reviewer may meet the criterion. However, when evaluating the case as a whole, what may matter is the level of the competition or journal, the status of the work being judged, how often you are invited and why you were chosen as an expert.
High salary
The regulations do not contain a universal requirement to earn more than 90%, 95% or 99% of professionals. The criterion requires showing high income compared with other professionals in the relevant field.
So it is important to choose the right basis for comparison, taking into account the profession, level of experience, country or region, type of employment and the period in which the income was earned. A general national average salary may be an unsuitable benchmark.
Leading or critical role
A senior position by itself does not prove a critical role. It helps to show:
which decisions the applicant was responsible for;
which projects or areas they developed;
what results were achieved thanks to their work;
why their participation was essential;
whether the organization has a distinguished reputation.
Media publications
A large number of mentions does not always mean broad professional recognition. USCIS may consider the content of the materials, the outlet’s audience, reach and reputation, and whether the publications are independent.
Promotional texts, press releases and materials prepared by the applicant are evaluated differently from independent editorial publications.
Recommendation letters
Expert letters help explain the significance of complex projects and professional contributions. The most convincing letters contain specific facts: work results, the degree of impact, usage figures for a development and an explanation of how the author knows about these achievements.
General words of praise without supporting documents usually carry less weight. All letters must accurately reflect the position of the person who signed them and not contradict the other materials.
What the “preponderance of the evidence” standard means
In most immigration proceedings USCIS applies the preponderance of the evidence standard. This means that, based on the materials submitted, the claimed facts must be more likely true than not.
This is not the criminal standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt”, but it is not a mere formality either. The burden of proof is on the applicant or petitioner. The documents must be credible, relevant to the case and together confirm every mandatory element of the category. This standard is described in more detail in the USCIS Policy Manual.
Should you try to meet more than three criteria?
Additional criteria can strengthen a petition if they are backed by quality evidence and support the overall argument. But there is no universal “three plus one or two more criteria” rule in the law.
Sometimes four or five strong areas really do make a case more convincing. In other cases, adding weak materials increases the size of the petition without proving a higher professional level.
So it is more useful to ask not only “how many criteria are met”, but several other questions too:
What does each criterion say about the applicant’s standing in the profession?
Is the significance of the achievements confirmed by independent sources?
Can the applicant’s results be compared with those of other professionals?
Does the evidence add up to a consistent picture of professional recognition?
Does the material confirm exactly the standard that applies to the chosen category?
How to prepare your case for the USCIS final merits determination
Define your field clearly
A definition that is too broad makes it hard to compare the applicant with peers, while an artificially narrow one may look unjustified. The field should match your real specialization, experience and intended work in the US.
Separate the fact of an achievement from its significance
A diploma, award, publication or jury invitation confirms a fact. Separate evidence should explain the scale: selection conditions, number of participants, reputation of the organizers, reach and significance for the profession.
Use reliable comparisons
Income, commercial results, citations and other metrics must be compared with relevant data. It is important to explain why the chosen source and comparison group fit the applicant’s profession.
Prove impact with results
If the applicant claims to have made a significant contribution, it helps to show who used their work and how, what changes it led to and what measurable results it produced.
Check that the materials are consistent
Dates, job titles, duties, income, projects and other information must match across the forms, résumé, letters and exhibits. Inaccuracies can cast doubt on the credibility of the entire case.
Explain how you will continue working in the US
For EB-1A a job offer is not required, but you need to show that you intend to continue working in your field. For O-1, the work in the US must match the area of extraordinary ability and the terms of the petition filed.
An approved petition is not yet a visa or a green card
Petition approval confirms only one stage of the process.
For O-1, an applicant outside the US usually needs to apply for a visa at a consulate separately after Form I-129 is approved. The consular officer reviews the application form, documents, whether the purpose of the trip matches the stated work, and possible grounds of visa ineligibility. The process is described on the State Department page on temporary worker visas.
At the same time, tourist visa rules cannot automatically be applied to O-1. According to the Foreign Affairs Manual, an O-1 applicant does not have to maintain a foreign residence they have no intention of abandoning. Filing an immigrant petition is also not in itself a reason to deny O-1. But you must show that the trip matches the permitted temporary activity.
If USCIS approved not only the O-1 petition but also a change of status inside the US, you do not need to apply for a visa right away. You will need one for re-entry after traveling abroad.
For EB-1A, approval of Form I-140 also does not automatically mean a green card. The applicant still has to go through adjustment of status inside the US or consular processing abroad. An immigrant visa number must be available, and the applicant must meet the requirements for permanent residence and have no insurmountable grounds of inadmissibility. The adjustment of status requirements are listed in the USCIS Policy Manual.
Key takeaways
Three criteria are a minimum threshold, not a formula for guaranteed approval. USCIS evaluates the quality, reliability and significance of the evidence, and then considers the applicant’s professional history as a whole.
A strong petition should not just list achievements, but consistently show:
that the applicant has actually met the requirements of the specific criteria;
why their achievements matter in the field;
how their standing differs from that of other professionals;
whether the overall level of recognition meets the O-1 or EB-1A standard.
The outcome always depends on the specific circumstances and evidence. This material is for information only and does not replace individual legal advice.
FAQ
Do three criteria guarantee O-1 or EB-1A approval?
No. Three criteria let you pass the minimum stage of the review, after which USCIS considers the evidence as a whole and checks it against the overall standard of the category.
What is a final merits determination?
It is the final assessment of all the evidence. USCIS determines whether the petition shows the required level of professional recognition, not just the existence of individual documents under the criteria.
Does meeting five or six criteria increase the chances?
It may, if the additional criteria are backed by strong and relevant evidence. The number of criteria alone does not guarantee approval.
Do you have to be in the top 1% of professionals?
The O-1A and EB-1A regulations refer to a small percentage of professionals who have risen to the top of their field, but do not set a universal numerical “top 1%” figure. How the comparison is made depends on the profession and the available evidence.
Does I-129 approval guarantee an O-1 visa?
No. If the applicant is outside the US, a separate consular review takes place after the petition is approved.
Does I-140 approval mean the applicant already has a green card?
No. After the I-140 you need to go through adjustment of status or consular processing. In addition, an immigrant visa number must be available.

Comments