EB-1A and EB-2 NIW: New Case Evaluation Standards, Realities and Outlook
For a long time, EB-1A and EB-2 NIW were the most popular and fastest ways to get a green card. No employer needed, no queue, a high approval rate, and suitable for a wide range of people. If you wanted and could afford it, you could pay extra for premium processing and get a decision in 15 days.
Since Q3 2024, the approval situation for EB-2 NIW has sharply worsened, and the approval rate keeps falling quarter after quarter; in 2025 EB-1A has also “lost ground”.
In this article we cover:
How the standards for evaluating EB-1A and EB-2 NIW cases have changed;
What matters for approval in 2025 in each category;
The upcoming 2026 reform of EB-1A and EB-2 NIW: what immigrants should expect.
EB-1A: why the best and most extraordinary get denied
The EB-1A category is for people with extraordinary ability in various fields: business, science, athletics, culture and education.
For EB-1A, the approval rate was 72.7% in Q2 2025 and 67% in Q3. At first glance, a 5-point drop is not critical, but looking at the trend, it is the lowest approval rate in the past 3 years.

Today, the 3 most common reasons for denial are:
The officer does not see sustained acclaim in your field;
You have not proven that you are among the leading professionals in your field;
There is no convincing evidence of industry-wide recognition.
When you start working on an EB-1A case, it is important to understand that the officer may accept 5, 7 or even all 10 criteria (you need to meet 3 of 10 for this visa).
And still deny the petition!
Meeting the criteria is only part of the work on a case and the first step of the officer’s review. In 2025 it is much more important to work on the “final merits” and “sustained acclaim”.
How is sustained acclaim proven?
The petition should be built around your exceptional standing: you need to show and prove that you are in the top 1% of professionals in your field and an undisputed leader among your industry peers.
There should be no long gaps in what you do and in your achievements. For example, if you had many competitions and awards and worked in a top position at a large company, and then there was a 2–3 year gap, and now your position is lower and there are no achievements — that is a reason to deny.
There should always be growth! And that growth should be gradual, not all your achievements “happening” within one year.
Rapid, impulsive growth, media activity and visibility (articles, competitions, judging) over a short period show your productivity as a professional, but not sustained acclaim.
USCIS officers look at your career trajectory. If all your achievements are concentrated in the last months before filing, it looks like “preparing for immigration” rather than the natural development of an outstanding professional. A documented contribution to your field. An important part of the petition should be a justification of how your work has influenced the development of the field. For example, how often your work has been cited in research, or how many people have used your patent/methodology.
It is also important to describe in detail what you plan to do in the US. This part needs not just “plans off the top of your head” but, as elsewhere, specifics. For example, you can attach an offer from an employer or a business plan. Remember: quality always matters more than quantity!
You do not need 20 articles or 15 recommendation letters. Outdated achievements or every competition you ever entered, added just for volume, will only weaken the case — choose only the strongest and most significant accomplishments.
In addition, a large number of achievements in different directions can confuse the immigration officer as to how you are applying: as a professional or a scientist, as an outstanding entrepreneur or as an extraordinary stylist.
There is the petition, there is the main line, and every argument should strengthen it.
EB-2 NIW: the “national interest” crisis. What officers want to see
The EB-2 NIW immigrant visa allows foreign professionals to get a green card without a sponsoring employer. To have the employer requirement waived, you need to prove that your work benefits the US and is in its national interest. This is the visa with the most dramatic approval situation in 2025. The difference between the approval rate in 2022, when it was almost 95%, and today is significant.

As of October 2025, the EB-2 NIW approval picture is as follows:
Q1 2025 — 62.7%;
Q2 2025 — 67.3%;
Q3 2025 — 54%.
Why are there so many EB-2 NIW denials?
1. The growing popularity of EB-2 NIW in 2022–2023 meant that the number of applications increased, but their quality dropped sharply.
The huge influx of EB-2 NIW cases meant that the immigration service could not keep up and a large backlog built up. Over time the approach to evaluating cases became stricter, and when USCIS finally got to the petitions filed at the peak of approvals, it is logical that weak cases had no chance left.
As the backlog is cleared and unviable petitions are weeded out, approval statistics keep inevitably falling.
2. The second global factor behind the EB-2 NIW crisis is the case evaluation standards.
In 2024–2025, USCIS became much stricter in assessing the applicant’s work in terms of how well it serves US national interests. USCIS officers pay more attention to clear, measurable benefits to the United States rather than just general statements about potential contributions.
Which factors matter to USCIS when deciding an EB-2 NIW petition
1. How well the applicant’s project serves the national interest
You need specific evidence that the applicant’s work will benefit the US on a national scale.
The intended benefit should not be limited to your company or your employer, or a small county. What matters is how it will affect the region or what benefit it will bring to society as a whole.
USCIS now denies petitions in which applicants simply emphasize the importance of their profession without demonstrating its specific impact on the country. This needs to be proven with numbers and calculations.
For example, developing a drug may qualify if the focus is on the public health benefit rather than the company’s profit.
2. USCIS requires a clearer link between the person’s education, work experience and proposed work in the US
You need to state whether you will work in this field through a job at a specific company or in other ways.
For example, we have clients who have an employer in the US but self-petitioned — and again, the emphasis was on the project they were already working on at the company.
If you already work for a US company, you need to be careful about how you prove the benefit of your work to the US.
If you emphasize a shortage of workers in your specialty in the US, there is a high risk of denial. A labor shortage is a very important concept for employer-sponsored EB-2 and EB-3 visas. Those programs were created specifically to fill shortages of US workers with immigrants. That is what the PERM labor certification process is for.
So when deciding, the officer may agree that there is a labor shortage but deny the petition because you chose the wrong visa for it.
3. Measurable evidence and the ability to carry out the project
In the petition you need to show how you will carry out the project in the US and that you have every opportunity to do so.
Measurable indicators are also important here to demonstrate the potential impact of your venture on the US economy. For example, projected revenue or job creation.
You need to provide a clear plan of action, including:
achievements that confirm your competence.
business plans must be backed by supporting documents: contracts, funding commitments or clear indicators of consumer demand, evidence of investment, funding or partnerships.
Do not “dilute” the petition with weak arguments:
avoid general or template letters;
do not attach every diploma or certificate you have. Focus on evidence directly related to your project or work.
the more vague achievements there are in your petition, the more doubts it will raise for the officer. If there are no specific numbers and results, it is better to leave it out.
4. The upcoming reform of EB-1A and EB-2 NIW immigrant petitions
In January 2026, USCIS is expected to change the process for EB-1A and EB-2 NIW visas. This became known after a rule called “Reform of Immigrant Worker Petitions” (RIN 1615-AC85) was included in the regulatory agenda . According to the plan, the proposed rule will be published in January 2026, followed by a public comment period.
In practice, the changes will take effect no earlier than the end of 2026, and current petitions will be reviewed under the existing rules until the new standards officially take effect.
Five main areas of the reform
1. Some provisions of the Policy Manual (USCIS internal guidance) are expected to gain the force of law.
The main goal: to minimize subjectivity in evaluating petitions.
2. Clarifying evidentiary requirements for EB-1A, EB-1B and EB-2 NIW
The reform aims to clearly define which documents and evidence are required for each category, including:
EB-1A (extraordinary ability)
EB-1B (outstanding professors and researchers)
EB-2 NIW (national interest)
Physicians of national or international standing
Today USCIS officers rely on precedent decisions (such as Matter of Dhanasar for NIW) and internal memos.
A clear list of criteria is expected, which should make decisions more consistent thanks to clear requirements. On the other hand, there are plans, but nobody has seen the wording yet.
3. Updating outdated rules
Many rules for employment-based green cards were written more than 30 years ago, when:
Startups did not exist, nor did many professions;
Remote work was rare;
Business principles were completely different.
Possible changes:
Potentially more flexible requirements for the structure of sponsoring companies;
Recognition of new forms of employment relationships;
BUT: stricter control over non-standard situations is also possible.
4. Fighting fraud
DHS plans to:
Define what counts as a bona fide job offer
Clarify the authority to conduct site visits (similar to H-1B inspections)
Expand internal verification tools
What this means:
More checks of the legitimacy of employment relationships
Possible workplace inspections (currently rare for EB categories)
Stricter oversight
5. Fixing technical errors
DHS will correct typos and inconsistencies in cross-references in existing rules, which should reduce confusion when reviewing petitions.
What is important to understand and how to prepare
If you have been considering EB-1A or EB-2 NIW as a way to immigrate to the US, it is better not to delay filing while waiting for “better times”. If work on your case has already started, it is worth speeding up. In the current political climate and immigration policy, you should not expect additional clarifications to make the process simpler and more transparent. On the contrary, the requirements and the methods of assessing them are most likely to become even stricter.
Be prepared for a high likelihood of receiving a Request for Evidence when you file (a general trend across all categories), and take this into account when planning your timeline.
3 key factors for approval:
convincing arguments;
strong evidence;
a logical narrative and clear presentation of your position.
Remember that USCIS officers are not experts in every field. They do not always understand the applicant’s expertise or significance or what their contribution is, so it is important to add context to the petition, written clearly and accessibly.
If you are ready to start your US immigration journey with a team of professionals who work for results and stake their reputation on it, you can book a consultation with me — licensed US attorney Elena Manilich.

Comments