top of page

← Back to the knowledge base

O-1, EB-1 and EB-2 NIW Criteria: What You Need to Prove

2 days ago
14 min read

O-1, EB-1 and EB-2 NIW are often grouped under the informal name “talent visas”. Legally, however, they are different immigration routes with different requirements.

  • O-1 is a temporary nonimmigrant category for working in the US.

  • EB-1 and EB-2 are immigrant categories that can lead to a green card.

  • EB-2 NIW is not a separate category, but an option to obtain a waiver of the job offer and labor certification requirements within EB-2.


Each category has its own standard of proof. That is why you cannot simply assemble one set of awards, publications and recommendation letters and use it unchanged for O-1A, O-1B, EB-1A or EB-2 NIW.


Quick comparison of requirements

Category

Main formal threshold

Who files the petition

O-1A

A major international award or at least 3 of 8 criteria

A US employer or agent

O-1B

A significant award or nomination, or at least 3 of 6 criteria

A US employer or agent

EB-1A

A major international achievement or at least 3 of 10 criteria, plus a final merits review of the case

Self-petition is possible

EB-1B

At least 2 of 6 criteria, international recognition, experience and a permanent position

A US employer

EB-1C

Requirements for the managerial role and the relationship between companies; no list of achievements

A US employer

EB-2

An advanced degree or exceptional ability; for exceptional ability — at least 3 of 6 criteria

Usually the employer

EB-2 NIW

EB-2 eligibility plus the three NIW prongs

Self-petition is possible


How USCIS evaluates the criteria


The formal number of criteria is only part of the analysis. USCIS checks:

  1. Whether the documents submitted match the literal wording of each claimed criterion.

  2. Whether the evidence as a whole shows the required level of recognition, achievement, expertise or impact.


For EB-1A, EB-1B and EB-2 Exceptional Ability, USCIS applies a two-step review: first it checks the minimum number of criteria, then it looks at the evidence as a whole. For O-1, it is also important whether the case as a whole shows the level of achievement set for that category.


The law does not require you to submit one or two criteria above the minimum. Additional criteria can strengthen a petition if they are backed by convincing and independent evidence. Their number alone does not guarantee approval.


The USCIS approach to O-1 is set out in Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, and to EB-1A in Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2.


O-1A criteria


O-1A is for professionals with extraordinary ability in science, education, business or athletics.


The applicant must show sustained national or international acclaim and that they intend to continue working in their area of extraordinary ability in the US.


Eligibility can be shown by:

  • receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, such as a Nobel Prize-level award; or

  • evidence under at least three of eight criteria.


1. National or international awards


You need to show receipt of recognized national or international prizes or awards for excellence in the field.

USCIS may consider:

  • the reputation of the award;

  • eligibility requirements for participants;

  • the selection rules and how competitive it is;

  • the qualifications of the judges;

  • the number of participants and winners;

  • the geographic and professional scope of the competition.


A certificate or a photo from the ceremony usually does not explain the significance of an award. It helps to include the competition rules, information about the organizer, the jury, past winners and independent coverage of the award.


2. Membership in professional associations


The association must admit members based on outstanding achievements, as judged by recognized national or international experts.


Regular paid membership, registration after graduating from university, or joining based on education, years of experience or job title usually do not meet this criterion.


It is important to document:

  • the requirements for candidates;

  • the application review process;

  • the qualifications of the decision-makers;

  • the specific achievements required for admission.


3. Published material about the applicant and their work


This covers material about the applicant, related to their professional work, published in professional, major trade or other major media.


You should document:

  • the content of the publication and how it relates to the applicant’s work;

  • the author, title and date of the material;

  • the audience and reputation of the publication;

  • the independence of the source.


A brief mention of a name, a promotional company profile or a reprinted press release usually carries less weight than a full editorial piece about the professional’s results.


4. Judging the work of others


This criterion may include:

  • serving on the jury of a professional competition;

  • peer-reviewing scientific articles;

  • reviewing grant applications;

  • serving on an expert or certification panel;

  • other professional evaluation in your own or an allied field.


Ideally, document not only the invitation, but that you actually performed the duties. Event programs, jury lists, correspondence, completed reviews, certificates and letters from organizers can be used for this.


5. Original contributions of major significance


This means an original scientific, scholarly or business contribution of major significance to the field.


Novelty alone is not enough. You need to show the impact of the result, for example:

  • adoption of your work by other organizations;

  • commercial or practical use;

  • measurable results;

  • professional discussion or citations;

  • influence on methods, practice or industry standards;

  • independent expert opinions.


Recommendation letters can be helpful, but they are most convincing when their conclusions are backed by objective documents.


6. Authorship of scholarly articles


This covers scientific and other scholarly articles published in professional journals or major media.


In addition to authorship, it helps to document:

  • the professional nature of the material;

  • the target audience;

  • the reputation of the publication;

  • peer review, where applicable;

  • the impact of the publication.


Marketing copy, a corporate blog post or a general-interest popular article does not always qualify as a scholarly article.


7. Critical or essential role


You need to show that the applicant performed a critical or essential function for an organization or establishment with a distinguished reputation.


These are two separate elements:

  1. The significance of the professional’s role.

  2. The distinguished reputation of the organization or the relevant division.


A well-known employer by itself does not prove an employee’s critical role. You need documents on your authority, responsibilities, specific results and the impact of your work on the organization.


8. High salary or other remuneration


The applicant’s salary or other remuneration must be high compared with others in the relevant field.


When comparing, the following may matter:

  • the profession and seniority level;

  • the country and region;

  • the period in which the income was earned;

  • gross or net amount;

  • the compensation structure;

  • the type of employment.


Evidence includes contracts, tax documents, income statements and reliable data on the pay of professionals at a comparable level.


The official requirements are on the USCIS page about O-1 and in 8 CFR § 214.2(o).


O-1B criteria


O-1B covers two groups:

  • people with extraordinary ability in the arts;

  • people with extraordinary achievement in the film and television industry.


The standards for these groups differ.


In the arts, you need to show distinction — a level of achievement substantially above that ordinarily encountered, where the person is prominent, leading or well known in their field.


For film and television, the standard is extraordinary achievement — a very high level of professional accomplishment and recognition as outstanding, notable or leading in the industry.


The applicant must show that they have received, or been nominated for, a significant national or international award — such as an Oscar, Emmy or Grammy — or meet at least three of six criteria.


1. Lead role in distinguished productions or events


You need to show that the applicant has performed, and will perform, in a lead or starring role in productions or events with a distinguished reputation.


Evidence may include:

  • contracts;

  • programs and posters;

  • reviews;

  • publications;

  • promotional materials;

  • information about the reputation of the production or event.


2. National or international recognition


Recognition can be shown through reviews and other published material in major newspapers, magazines, professional and trade publications.


USCIS assesses the content of the material, the reach of the publication and how far it actually confirms the applicant’s professional achievements.


3. Lead, starring or critical role for distinguished organizations


You need to show the significance of the applicant’s role and, separately, the distinguished reputation of the organization or establishment.


These can be theaters, studios, production companies, creative collectives, festivals and other recognized industry players.


4. Commercial or critically acclaimed success


The following can be used:

  • box office receipts;

  • ratings of film and TV projects;

  • record and ticket sales;

  • professional rankings;

  • critics’ reviews;

  • other indicators of notable commercial or professional results.


If a large team worked on the project, it is important to explain the applicant’s own contribution to its success.


5. Significant recognition from experts and organizations


Confirmation from professional organizations, critics, government agencies and recognized experts is suitable.


A letter or opinion should ideally state:

  • the author’s qualifications;

  • how the author knows the applicant’s work;

  • the specific achievements the assessment is based on;

  • the significance of those achievements for the field.


6. High salary or substantial remuneration


The income or offered remuneration must be high compared with others in the relevant field.


For O-1B Arts, comparable evidence is allowed if the standard criteria do not readily apply to a particular creative profession. For the film and television industry, the rules do not allow comparable evidence.


The differences are explained in more detail in the USCIS Policy Manual.


You cannot self-petition for O-1. The petitioner must be a US employer, a US agent, or a foreign employer through a US agent. Under certain conditions, a separate company owned by the applicant can file the petition, but a person cannot be the petitioner on their own behalf.


EB-1A criteria


EB-1A is for people with extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business or athletics.


The applicant must show:

  • sustained national or international acclaim;

  • recognition of their achievements in the field;

  • intent to continue working in that field in the US;

  • the prospective benefit of their work to the US.


No job offer or labor certification is required. Form I-140 can be self-filed.


EB-1A eligibility is shown by a major internationally recognized achievement or at least three of ten criteria.


The ten EB-1A criteria

  1. National or international prizes or awards for excellence.

  2. Membership in associations that admit members based on outstanding achievements, as judged by recognized experts.

  3. Published material about the applicant and their work in professional, major trade or other major media.

  4. Judging the work of others, individually or on a panel.

  5. Original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic or business contributions of major significance.

  6. Authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media.

  7. Display of work at artistic exhibitions or showcases. This criterion applies specifically to artistic work. Showing a commercial product at an industry conference is not necessarily an artistic exhibition.

  8. A leading or critical role for organizations with a distinguished reputation.

  9. A high salary or other significantly high remuneration compared with others in the field.

  10. Commercial success in the performing arts, shown for example by box office receipts or sales of recordings and videos.


If the standard criteria do not readily apply to the applicant’s profession, comparable evidence is allowed. You must explain why a particular criterion does not apply and how the evidence offered is comparable to it.


Final merits determination for EB-1A


Formally meeting three criteria does not mean automatic approval. After checking the individual criteria, USCIS carries out a final merits determination of the evidence.


The case as a whole must show that the applicant:

  • is among the small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field;

  • has sustained national or international acclaim;

  • has been recognized for their achievements;

  • will continue working in the relevant field in the US.


That is why the independence of sources, the scale of achievements, how long the recognition has lasted and the real impact of the professional’s work matter so much.


The official requirements are published on the USCIS page about EB-1 and in Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2.


EB-1B criteria


EB-1B is for outstanding professors and researchers.


For this category you need to show:

  • international recognition of the applicant as outstanding in a specific academic field;

  • at least three years of teaching or research experience;

  • an offer of a qualifying permanent position in the US.


The position must be:

  • a tenured or tenure-track teaching position;

  • a comparable permanent teaching position;

  • a permanent research position.


To show international recognition, you must submit at least two of six types of evidence:

  1. Major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement in the academic field.

  2. Membership in associations that require outstanding achievements.

  3. Published material by others in professional publications about the applicant’s work.

  4. Judging the work of others in the same or an allied academic field.

  5. Original scientific or scholarly research contributions.

  6. Authorship of scholarly books or articles in journals with international circulation.


After checking the two criteria, USCIS reviews the evidence as a whole to determine whether the applicant has in fact been internationally recognized as outstanding.


Experience gained while studying for a degree counts only under special conditions. For example, research work may count if the degree was obtained and the applicant’s research was recognized as outstanding. Teaching experience during studies may count if the applicant had full responsibility for the course taught.


The petitioner can be a university, another institution of higher education or a qualifying private employer. A private organization must have documented accomplishments in an academic field and at least three full-time researchers.


Detailed requirements are given in USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 3.


EB-1C requirements


EB-1C is for multinational executives and managers. This category has no list of criteria related to awards, publications, judging or income.


Instead, you must prove:

  • a qualifying relationship between the foreign and US entities as defined by law — for example, a parent and subsidiary, branch or affiliate relationship;

  • that the applicant worked outside the US for at least one year within the applicable three-year period;

  • the managerial or executive nature of the work abroad;

  • that the US company has been doing business for at least one year;

  • an offer of a managerial or executive position in the US.


USCIS looks at actual duties, not just the job title. A title such as director, CEO or head of department does not by itself prove managerial or executive capacity. What matters is authority, company structure, the number and qualifications of subordinates, the level of decision-making and the volume of operational tasks.


If the applicant is already working in the US for the petitioning company, there are additional rules for determining the applicable three-year period.


Official guidance is published in USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 4.


EB-2 requirements


EB-2 has two main bases:

  1. A profession requiring an advanced degree.

  2. Exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business.


The “three of six criteria” rule applies only to exceptional ability.


EB-2 for advanced degree professionals

Eligibility can be shown by:

  • a US degree above the bachelor’s level or its foreign equivalent; or

  • a US bachelor’s degree or its foreign equivalent plus at least five years of progressive post-degree professional experience.


Progressive experience means growth in knowledge, responsibility and the complexity of the work performed.


For regular EB-2, the offered position must also require the relevant qualification. As a rule, a permanent job offer and labor certification are required. These requirements can be waived if a National Interest Waiver is approved.


EB-2 for people with exceptional ability


Exceptional ability means a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the field.


Initially, you must submit at least three of six types of evidence:

  1. A diploma, certificate or other record of education related to the area of exceptional ability.

  2. Letters from current or former employers documenting at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation.

  3. A professional license or certification.

  4. A salary or other remuneration demonstrating exceptional ability.

  5. Membership in professional associations.

  6. Recognition for achievements and significant contributions by peers, government agencies, or professional or business organizations.


If the standard criteria do not readily apply to the profession, comparable evidence is allowed.


After checking the minimum number of criteria, USCIS reviews all the evidence together. It must show a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the field.


Official requirements are published on the USCIS EB-2 page and in 8 CFR § 204.5(k).


EB-2 NIW requirements


A National Interest Waiver allows the usual permanent job offer requirement and the related labor certification to be waived if USCIS finds this to be in the US national interest.


First, the applicant must establish EB-2 eligibility:

  • as an advanced degree professional; or

  • as a person of exceptional ability.


Only then does USCIS move on to the three NIW prongs.


1. The proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance


USCIS evaluates not the applicant’s profession in general, but the specific line of work they intend to pursue in the US — the proposed endeavor.


Substantial merit can be economic, scientific, technological, educational, cultural, medical or social. Immediate profit or direct job creation are not mandatory.


National importance is determined by the endeavor’s prospective impact. The project does not have to physically cover the whole country, but you need to show effects beyond the ordinary benefit to a single employer, client or local business.


High demand for a profession or a general labor shortage does not by itself prove the national importance of the applicant’s specific endeavor.


2. The applicant is well positioned to advance the endeavor


USCIS may consider:

  • education and professional skills;

  • past experience and achievements;

  • a well-developed plan;

  • progress already made;

  • available funding;

  • interest from investors, clients and partners;

  • grants, contracts and letters of intent;

  • support from government, research or professional organizations.


The applicant does not have to guarantee the project’s success. However, you need to show that you have the knowledge, experience, resources and real capacity to advance it.


3. On balance, it would benefit the US to waive the job offer and labor certification


At this stage, USCIS weighs the circumstances of the case and decides whether a waiver of the standard procedure is justified.


Factors in the applicant’s favor may include:

  • the nature of the work, where tying it to a single employer is difficult or impractical;

  • the particular value of the applicant’s knowledge and past results;

  • the benefit of the proposed work to the US even if other qualified workers are available;

  • the urgency or public importance of the work;

  • the negative consequences that a delay caused by the usual labor certification process could bring.


It is not enough to simply claim that the profession is in demand, that the project will create jobs or that the applicant’s work is good for the economy. You need to connect the person’s qualifications, the specific plan of work and the expected benefit to the US.


Current guidance is given in USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5. In January 2025, USCIS also clarified how EB-2 eligibility is assessed and how it relates to the proposed endeavor: USCIS Updates Guidance on EB-2 National Interest Waiver Petitions.


What makes evidence convincing


It is usually not enough to attach the main document without explaining its significance.


For example:

  • for an award, add the selection rules and information about the jury and the scale of the competition;

  • for a publication — information about the audience and reputation of the outlet;

  • for a high salary — data on the pay of comparable professionals;

  • for a critical role — a description of the applicant’s authority, results and impact;

  • for an original contribution — independent confirmation of the use and significance of the result;

  • for a recommendation letter — information about the author’s qualifications and the factual basis for their conclusions.


A large number of documents does not make up for a lack of argument. The petition should make clear:

  1. What fact each document proves.

  2. How it relates to the wording of the criterion.

  3. Why this fact matters for the overall assessment of the applicant.


Documents in other languages must be accompanied by a full English translation. The translator must certify that the translation is complete and accurate and that they are competent to translate.


An approved petition is not yet a visa or a green card


Approval of Form I-129 for O-1, or Form I-140 for EB-1 and EB-2, confirms eligibility for the chosen category, but does not always complete the immigration process.


Depending on the circumstances, you may need to:

  • obtain a visa at a consulate;

  • enter the US;

  • file Form I-485;

  • go through consular processing for an immigrant visa;

  • wait for a visa number to become available;

  • pass the review of grounds of inadmissibility.


An approved I-140 does not by itself grant permanent resident status. Similarly, an approved I-129 does not always replace getting a visa at a consulate if the applicant is outside the US or travels abroad.

This material is for general information only and does not replace an analysis of your specific situation by an immigration attorney.

Frequently asked questions


Is it enough to meet the minimum number of criteria?

Not always. The minimum number lets you pass the initial review, but USCIS also evaluates the quality of the evidence and the applicant’s overall professional profile.


Do I need to prove more criteria than the law requires?

There is no such requirement. Additional strong criteria can help, but the number alone does not increase the chances of approval.


Are the O-1A and EB-1A criteria the same?

They partly overlap, but the wording and the overall standard differ. An O-1A approval does not mean you automatically qualify for EB-1A.


Can I self-petition for O-1?

No. The petition must be filed by a US employer or agent. A separate company owned by the applicant can be the petitioner under certain conditions, but a person cannot file an O-1 on their own behalf.


Can I self-petition for EB-1A or EB-2 NIW?

Yes. These categories allow you to file Form I-140 yourself, without a petitioning employer.


Is EB-2 NIW only for people with a university degree?

No. The applicant must show either an advanced degree or exceptional ability, and then separately meet the three NIW prongs.


Is it enough to show that my profession is in demand in the US?

No. Demand for the profession can be part of the context, but for NIW you must prove the national importance of your specific endeavor and your ability to advance it.


Does an approved I-140 guarantee a green card?

No. After the petition is approved, you must complete adjustment of status or consular processing, wait for a visa number to become available and meet the other immigration requirements.


Official sources

Related Posts

See All

Comments


← Back to the knowledge base

bottom of page